top of page
  • YouTube
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

FALL 2025

Beyond the Female Gothic: Wild Women in Charlotte Dacre’s Zofloya and Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights

Blythe Meacham 

Angelo State University

Meacham Blythe.JPEG

Blythe is a third year student at Angelo State University working towards her BA/MA in English. Originally from Idaho, she currently lives in San Angelo, Texas.

book_edited.jpg

"THE FEMALE GOTHIC":
AUTHORS AND HEROINES

"BEAUTY AND THE BEAST":
ZOFLOYA AND THE EVOLUTION OF THE FEMALE GOTHIC

CIVILIZATION AND WILDNESS IN WUTHERING HEIGHTS:

Wuthering Heights contains many striking similarities to Zofloya, though its ideas play out more subtly and realistically on the Yorkshire moors. Brontë’s heroine, Catherine, also pushes at the boundaries of domestic civilization through her natural passions, although less overtly than does Victoria. The novel follows the inhabitants of the two houses of Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross Grange over the course of two generations, as narrated by housekeeper Nelly Dean to the new tenant Lockwood. The story begins with old Mr. Earnshaw bringing home to his two children – Catherine and Hindley – a foundling from Liverpool he calls Heathcliff. Like Victoria, Catherine’s early childhood is characterized by the lack of sufficient parental guidance, having lost both parents while she is young. “A wild, wick slip,” Nelly Dean calls her, running wild on the moors with Heathcliff – with whom she develops a codependency. Catherine’s nature is calmed somewhat by the civilizing force of first Fanny, her brother’s wife, and then the Lintons (Brontë 55). Catherine sustains an injury while she and Heathcliff trespass to spy on the Lintons, and she is forced to recoup at Thrushcross Grange under their refined influences. She returns to Wuthering Heights with a new frock and manner that distances her from her childhood companion Heathcliff. Through the new clothing and genteel company, Catherine is introduced to the societal and domestic role she is expected to fill. Eventually, she agrees to marry Edgar Linton, who, “handsome, and young, and cheerful, and rich,” comes from a “wealthy, respectable” house (85). This comes about as a result of her knowledge of these roles, although she confesses to Nelly that “In whichever place the soul lives… [she] is convinced [she] is wrong” (85). She describes a dream in which,
“... heaven did not seem to be my home; and I broke my heart with weeping to come back
to earth; and the angels were so angry that they flung me out, into the middle of the heath
on top of Wuthering Heights; where I woke sobbing for joy.” (86)
Gilbert and Gubar explore the concept of heaven and hell in Wuthering Heights, especially as it pertains to societal roles for women. The authors argue that the novel functions as a sort of response to Milton’s Paradise Lost, although with a reversal of the typical “fall” narrative. In this case, Catherine “falls” from what society might deem as hell – her wild childhood and androgynous “wholeness” with Heathcliff – into the established heaven of female grace and experience. Noting the historic difficulties in defining the exact genre the novel falls into, Gilbert and Gubar explore Wuthering Heights as a myth, specifically one that deals with female origins in culture and society. It particularly does this through Catherine’s loss and transition from her aforementioned childhood connections to her subsequent education through Frances and the Lintons. However, just as Catherine’s dream portends, this “heaven” of apparent domestic stability “does not seem to be [her] home” (Brontë 86).

​

The attempts to curb Catherine’s childhood wildness have not been entirely successful, causing her to adopt a sort of double character, as Nelly notes. A large aspect of this double life is her relationship with Heathcliff, who does not exist neatly within the bounds of the domestic sphere. His social status is ambiguous, as he was treated by the old Mr. Earnshaw as a son, but degraded to a laborer by Hindley. His heritage also alienates him. Although of ambiguous racial background, Heathcliff is consistently identified throughout the novel as an “other” in society. The Lintons speculate that he is a “gipsy,” “a little Lascar, or an American or Spanish castaway” (Brontë 62).  Beyond this, however, he is equated by various characters with something monstrous or devilish, and seems to have a corrupting influence on the inhabitants of Wuthering Heights after his mysterious return. Even Catherine, his friend, warns Isabella Linton that Heathcliff is “a fierce, pitiless, wolfish man” (104). Meyer argues that Brontë left his background deliberately ambiguous, as he is able to represent, alongside Catherine, the “resistant energies” of those “external to, subordinated to, marginalized by, or excluded from the British social order” (Meyer 102, 101).

​

It is through the relationship between the two that Catherine can express her “wildness” beyond the boundaries of the domestic role she stepped into when she agreed to marry Edgar. As she proclaims to Nelly, Heathcliff is “more myself than I am” (Brontë 86). His return, and the subsequent conflict between her two worlds, leads Catherine to a crisis of self. Secluding herself in her room and refusing food, Catherine lies on the edge of illness and madness until she is unable to recognize her own reflection in a mirror, thinking it a ghost. Nelly attempts to comfort her with assurances that “It was yourself, Mrs. Linton,” however these do not placate her (Brontë 121). In fact, Catherine seems even further disturbed at this thought, replying “Myself!…. It’s true then; that’s dreadful!” (121). Through this interaction, we become aware that, just as her reflection is unfamiliar to her, Catherine does not recognize the woman she has become. Rather, she longs for the wildness of her life at Wuthering Heights, begging Nelly to open the window and “let [her] have one breath” of the wind blowing in from the moor (121).

​

Eagleton notes that this scene reflects the central conflicts of Brontë’s novel, which stem from the central conflict of authentic, natural self versus civilization and social privilege. He analyzes the novel in terms of the power dynamics of those who are within or outside of domestic structure. It is within Catherine’s character that these conflicts are personified, as she struggles between the knowledge of her expected place within societal norms – knowledge gained from the cultivation of Fanny and the Lintons – and the wild passions of her childhood. The tension between these conflicts is expressed in how Catherine disrupts the boundaries of the civilized, domestic role she is expected to fulfill. She attempts to open up the enclosed household at Thrushcross Grange to Heathcliff, an entity who does not fit within the domestic structure. When this fails, her dissatisfaction begets violent passion, similar to Dacre’s Victoria. However, unlike Victoria, in Catherine this violence is directed inward, rather than outward, manifesting in the final illness that Nelly considers, at least partially, to be self-inflicted.

​

​​

  Von Sneidern interestingly draws a link between Heathcliff’s origin and the involvement of Liverpool in the trans-Atlantic slave trade during the novel’s set period. Although by the mid 19th century English sentiment was generally set against the institution of slavery, which was abolished in the decades before Brontë’s novel was published, the idea of Anglo-Saxon superiority and a kind of racial mythology was still prevalent. Von Sneidern argues that Brontë engages with this through Heathcliff’s entrance into Wuthering Heights, which upsets the “social equilibrium” and domestic structure of the household (175). Importantly, however, Brontë (through Catherine) does not seem to attribute Heathcliff’s baseness to his nature, but to his harsh and degrading upbringing under Hindley, a thought which “questions the very concept of race” and the various pseudo-scientific justifications for an Anglo-Saxon racial superiority (177).

1

1

CULTIVATING WOMEN: EDUCATION VS. PASSION IN THE GOTHIC NOVEL

REFERENCES

CONTINUE READING

Calves & Cow in Pasture

Maggie Burnett

Lone Star College - Montgomery

Beef was chosen as the center for this study since it is a household staple and grocery price increases continue to be a national concern for consumers. Studies published within the last 20 years, fully address the relationship between prices and supply lines; however, there is little research into product and goods price relationships. To understand the correlation of prices on a consumer level, individual products were chosen as follows: economic relations, including inflation and Covid-19; competing industries, such as milk and cheese and related products; supply inputs, such as gas and corn; and lastly, substitute goods, including pork, chicken, and fish and seafood. The price data was found using the Bureau of Labor Statistics...

300px-Mary_A._Nolan_(c._1910-1920).jpg

Sarah Coblentz

Southeastern Oklahoma State University

In January of 1919, 80-year-old Mary Nolan stood before the Columbia County Court and asked to be thrown in jail for participating in “Watchfires of Freedom.”  The fires were protests by the National Woman’s Party, a political organization that advocated for women’s suffrage, of which Nolan was a proud member. The party placed speeches delivered by President Woodrow Wilson while he was in Europe into a flaming urn in front of the White House.   This was Nolan’s third time before the court for her actions, but previously the court had no charge with which to convict...

ImperialismRobberBarons-wide.jpg

Nixon Gorka

The University of Texas at Tyler

As the Cold War came to a close, MI6 Deputy Chief Sir Gerry Warner was asked how he would describe the role of Britain’s foreign intelligence service to Queen Elizabeth II. The career intelligence officer answered rather starkly, telling the man opposite him that Britain’s foreign intelligence apparatus was “the last penumbra of empire.”...

bottom of page